The Case for For-Profit Charities

Essay — Volume 93, Issue 8

93 Va. L. Rev. 2017
Download PDF

Nonprofit firms may earn profits, but they may not distribute them to any affiliated persons. If a nonprofit firm has a “charitable” purpose under § 501(c)(3) of the tax code, the firm receives numerous tax advantages. For example, donors may deduct their donations to the firm from their taxable personal income. For-profit firms may distribute profits to affiliated persons, but receives no tax advantages for engaging in “charitable” activities. We argue that the law should not link tax benefits to corporate form in this way. There may be good arguments for recognizing the nonprofit form and good arguments for providing tax subsidies to charitable firms, but there is no good argument for making those tax subsidies available only to charities that adopt the nonprofit form. Indeed, there are reasons to think the ability to distribute profits to affiliates may both increase and improve charitable activities. Moreover, the extensive charitable activities of many for-profit commercial firms suggest that in the absence of discriminatory tax treatment for-profit charities would flourish. Therefore, the current tax benefits offered to charitable nonprofits should be extended to for-profit charities, and to the charitable activities of for-profit commercial firms.

Click on a link below to access the full text of this article. These are third-party content providers and may require a separate subscription for access.

  Volume 93 / Issue 8  

Jurisdictional Exceptionalism

By Michael G. Collins
93 Va. L. Rev. 1829

The Questionable Use of Custom in Intellectual Property

By Jennifer E. Rothman
93 Va. L. Rev. 1899

A New Model of Administrative Enforcement

By Robert J. Jackson, Jr. & David Rosenberg
93 Va. L. Rev. 1983

The Case for For-Profit Charities

By Anup Malani & Eric A. Posner
93 Va. L. Rev. 2017