The Promise of International Law

Book Review — Volume 92, Issue 3

92 Va. L. Rev. 533
Download PDF

In their recent book, The Limits of International Law, Professors Goldsmith and Posner throw down the gauntlet to scholars of international law. They advance a deeply pessimistic account of international law and its role in affecting state behavior — alleging that customary international fails to act as “an exogenous influence on states’ behavior,” and expressing skepticism that multinational collective action problems can be solved by treaty. This review represents a response to the book’s claims. It is demonstrated that there is no theoretical reason to conclude that international law is ineffective, whether it addresses bilateral or multilateral problems and whether it takes the form of written agreements or customary law. Adopting the same rational choice framework used by Goldsmith and Posner, it is shown that rational states have a reason to value a reputation for compliance with international law and, therefore, a reason to comply with their international legal obligations. The mechanism through which international law affects state behavior is obviously of central importance to those seeking to understand the international legal system. This review both explains the assumptions required to generate the results provided in The Limits of International Law and illustrates how more reasonable assumptions support a theory of international law in which state behavior is constrained by their international legal commitments.

Click on a link below to access the full text of this article. These are third-party content providers and may require a separate subscription for access.

  Volume 92 / Issue 3  

What Makes the D.C. Circuit Different? A Historical View

By John G. Roberts, Jr.
92 Va. L. Rev. 375

A Jurisprudence of Risk Assessment: Forecasting Harm among Prisoners, Predators, and Patients

By John Monahan
92 Va. L. Rev. 391

Exclusionary Amenities in Residential Communities

By Lior Strahilevitz
92 Va. L. Rev. 437

The Law Clerk Who Wrote Rasul v. Bush

By Joseph T. Thai
92 Va. L. Rev. 501